Leave a Message

Thank you for your message. We will be in touch with you shortly.

See all photos
Greg Mire

154 Underhill Avenue Unit: Building

$3,520,000 154 Underhill Avenue, New York City, NY 11238
PLEASE CONTACT US FOR A 3D/VIRTUAL TOUR: A design-forward, two-family, 20' limestone townhouse built to the highest green building standards in the heart of Prospect Heights. With modern finishes and conveniences juxtaposed with jaw dropping classic elements, this stunning residence was renovated with meticulous attention to detail.

PARLOR LEVEL: As you enter the owner's duplex, you will be immediately struck by the custom designed hat/coat rack and the encaustic tiles of the foyer foretelling the numerous unique details and care that went into crafting every corner of this wonderful home. Stepping into the living room, it is impossible to ignore the light pouring in from the front bay windows. These windows, like all of the windows in the home, are triple pane for maximum energy efficiency and sound reduction. The stunning red and white oak floor is repurposed from Carolina horse barns, and is laid in a gorgeous herringbone pattern. The spacious living area offers a bright and serene moment of relaxation yet, if you desire the ultimate movie night, a projector is hidden under the stairway and a screen magically appears by rolling a piece of art secured on a track to the side. Flowing seamlessly from the living area is the open kitchen featuring Italian oak cabinetry, a Miele electric range, a back splash with a clever plate holder, and a custom corian countertop designed by Mobili de Angelis including a built-in drying basin with a drain. The large island, composed of a combination of corian and wood, provides causal seating and also houses the oven which, like all of the appliances, have been chosen because they are the top choice for energy efficiency. Across, you will find a large walk-in pantry and powder room decked out with amazing repurposed design elements, both seamlessly concealed within a handsome herringbone wall with Forbes and Lomax light switches (which can also be found throughout the entire home). A dedicated dining area with breathtaking exposed wooden beams provides ample room for a formal dining table as well as cabinets for all of your entertaining essentials. An additional room with bay windows can serve a multitude of needs including a den, office, or playroom. A staircase from the parlor level also leads down to a paved and planted private back yard showcasing full sized trees, terraced planters, and plenty of room for the perfect summer bbq or children's wonderland.

UPPER LEVEL: After heading up the beautifully restored original wood staircase, you will arrive on the second floor, where you find three bedrooms. The spacious children's room with bay windows is in the front of the house, while the second bedroom in the middle features a wonderful skylight with an electric shade, and is perfect for either a nursery, guest bedroom, or home office. The exceptional master suite is in the rear of the home and offers plenty of room for king-sized furniture, a custom closet system, dedicated office nook, and private set back terrace built with reclaimed Cyprus from NYC water towers for those late night conversations or morning meditation. The encaustic floor tiles in the ensuite master bathroom provide a fun pop of color, and a beautiful marble topped, repurposed, mid century credenza serves as the dual sink vanity. With its stand up shower and marble enclosed deep soaking tub, the master bathroom fulfills your spa needs while the penny-tiled guest bath is the perfect spot for your guests and children's bath time. Original parquet floors with inlay are throughout the upper level, in addition to a Clearstory light well bringing in an abundance of sun.

BASEMENT: A laundry room for the main residence is on the way down to the partially finished basement, which is the home to a fully equipped gym, and multiple storage rooms.

GARDEN UNIT: A three-bedroom garden rental features gorgeous original parquet floors with inlay. A Schiffini kitchen is equipped with Corian counters, a Viking stove and range, Meile dishwasher, and it's own full size washer and dryer. The same high efficiency triple paned windows and doors and filtered energy recovery ventilation system as the main residence is also in this unit. This high income producing unit can be delivered with a tenant in place.

This thoughtfully and beautifully designed home has so much to offer aesthetically, but the icing on the cake is that it was also designed to the highest energy efficient and air quality standards. The entire townhouse has an almost net zero energy cost as a benefit from its 5.76kw "net metered" solar energy gathered from its rooftop solar panels. Built according to passive house principles, the triple paned European windows and doors plus the 6 inches of insulation in the walls keep it whisper quiet and amazingly energy efficient. There are even energy recovery ventilation units that bring filtered fresh air into each bedroom for the healthiest indoor environment imaginable. Furthermore, the house uses LED lighting throughout, can be temperature regulated by room and has a hot water heat pump in the basement that serves as a powerful basement dehumidifier.

Situated in the middle of a row of limestone homes, 154 Underhill Avenue is in one of the most ideal locations for access to the very best Brooklyn has to offer. A plethora of Brooklyn's famed treasures are right outside your door including the Brooklyn Museum, the Brooklyn Botanic Gardens, the main branch of the Brooklyn Library, and beautiful Prospect Park. The 2/3 and the Q/B express trains are all within a few blocks for a fast and easy commute into the city. An array of acclaimed new eateries, bakeries and wine shops are right around the block. Prospect Heights has become known as a foodie destination in the last several years. Great spots including the two Michelin starred restaurants Oxalis and Olmsted are within a few blocks, and amazing grocery stores, coffee shops and bars are steps away including Union Market, R&D specialty foods, Gold Star Beer Counter, Weather Up, Blue Marble Organic Ice Cream and Coffee, Bearded Lady, the famed Tom's restaurant and Stocked! which has the most amazing egg sandwich you will ever find! This wonderful home and location offers all the best of Brooklyn living in one package.
  • Sold
  • 7
  • 5.5
  • 1900
    Year Built
  • 3,233 Sq.Ft.
    Living Area

Features & Amenities

Area & Lot

  • Status: Sold
  • Living Space: 3,233 Sq.Ft.
  • MLS® ID: OLRS-0038170
  • Type: Townhouse
  • Year Built: 1900
  • Architecture Styles: Prewar


  • Total Bedrooms: 7
  • Total Bathrooms: 5.5
  • Full Bathrooms: 5
  • Half Bathrooms: 1
  • Laundry Room: Common Area

Exterior & Building

  • Stories: 3
  • Heat Type: Building Natural Gas, Natural Gas
  • Air Conditioning: Building Cooling, Window Unit(s)


  • Sales Price: $3,520,000
  • Zoning: R6B

154 Underhill Avenue Unit: Building

Work With Us

While sellers appreciate Greg's thorough, detail-oriented approach and the deep roster of local vendors he brings in to maximize a property's value, buyers and investors seek out his counsel due to his much-admired low-pressure approach.
Contact Us

Follow Us On Instagram